“She’s still with me… every note I sing, I sing for her.” That’s how American Idol finalist John Foster opened his hometown tribute — and from the very first shaky breath, hearts across the country broke wide open. Singing in honor of his late friend Maggie during the Idol finale, John didn’t just perform — he poured his soul into every word, and the pain, the love, the memory clung to every note like a whisper in the wind. But it was Maggie’s mother, eyes full of tears and voice barely holding together, who silenced the nation: “He kept her spirit alive tonight.” John may have finished second, but his tribute outshone any trophy. It wasn’t just a performance — it was a cry of grief, a vow of love, and a moment of healing that wrapped around every viewer like a warm, aching hug. -

“She’s Still With Me… Every Note I Sing, I Sing For Her.”

At the Hometown Visit in his hometown of Addis, Louisiana, Foster opened with this powerful line, immediately setting the tone for an emotionally charged performance. From the trembling first lyric, the nation was gripped.

A Song Born from Heartache

Foster performed “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” an original ballad written in memory of Maggie Dunn and her friend Caroline Gill—two teens tragically killed in a police chase on New Year’s Eve 2022. The song’s lyrics, such as:

“Each tear that falls on my guitar / Is a hug from afar,”

echoed his grief and devotion, culminating in a tear-filled declaration to Maggie: “I love you, Maggie” .

Watch the video down below and don’t forget to share this beautiful song with your friends and family…

John Foster Performs “Tell That Angel I Love Her” Live

John Foster also performed “Tell That Angel I Love Her,” in a heartfelt tribute to the late Maggie Dunn and Caroline Gill. He was close friends with the two girls. They were killed during a high speed police chase on New Year’s Eve 2022. A police officer hit their car while pursuing another car.

Foster performed this original song right before he advanced into the top 20 on American Idol last month.

You can see him getting emotional at the end. I can only imagine the journey this has been for him…a wild ride his friends Maggie and Caroline are surely proud of.

https://rebrand.ly/6af962 WAFB Channel 9

Posted by Liz Koh WAFB on Thursday, May 15, 2025

A Mother’s Unforgettable Response

Maggie’s mother, Erin Martin, was present in the audience. She watched, visibly emotional, clutching her heart as Foster sang. After the performance, Martin shared:

“My heart just melted… For John Foster to write and perform that song is a tangible example of the light and love Maggie left behind.”

She later told KARK that Foster’s tribute “kept her spirit alive tonight,” stopping the nation in its tracks.

Judges Praise: From Surprise to Reverence

The judges responded with deep admiration. Carrie Underwood, struck by the raw honesty, called Foster’s style “wonderfully throwback” and praised the tenderness in his voice. Luke Bryan admitted the performance erased all doubts about his place on the show, while Lionel Richie lauded it as “storytelling country” at its finest.

More Than a Contest—A Cultural Moment

Though Foster ultimately placed second to winner Jamal Roberts on May 18, 2025, his hometown homage became the night’s most unforgettable moment—a testament to love, grief, and resilience.

He used his platform not for fame, but to ensure Maggie’s memory endured. As her mother hoped, for a fleeting moment, “millions of people were thinking about my child” —spotlighting policy issues and honoring her life beyond the tragedy.

Final Thoughts

John Foster’s tribute was a profound reminder of music’s power to heal. In a competition often defined by vocal prowess, Foster’s raw authenticity struck a deeper chord, turning his moment into an anthem of remembrance—an enduring reminder that the heart behind the music truly matters.