John Foster’s cover of “House of the Rising Sun,” originally by The Animals, offers a unique and emotionally charged interpretation of the classic song. Foster’s version maintains the essence of the original while adding his personal touch with soulful vocal delivery and a stripped-back acoustic arrangement that allows the raw emotions of the song to shine.

Unlike the more energetic and blues-driven version by The Animals, Foster’s rendition feels more intimate and reflective. The acoustic guitar sets a more melancholic tone, and his fingerpicking style gently complements the somber lyrics. His voice, full of sincerity, adds weight to the narrative, bringing out the pain and regret expressed in the lyrics.

What makes Foster’s version stand out is the way he inhabits the character of the song. His vocal phrasing is thoughtful, often slowing down to draw out the emotion in specific lines. For instance, when he sings, “And it’s been the ruin of many a poor boy,” there’s a palpable sense of weary reflection in his voice, as if he’s lived through the mistakes he’s singing about. His rendition doesn’t just tell a story but rather paints a vivid emotional landscape that listeners can deeply connect with.

The pacing of the song in Foster’s cover is notably slower than the original, which helps create a more meditative atmosphere. This slower pace allows each line to resonate and gives space for the lyrics to be absorbed. The simplicity of the guitar arrangement also brings clarity to the lyrics, making them stand out in their rawness. Foster’s fingerpicking style doesn’t overwhelm the vocals; instead, it serves as a delicate backdrop that enhances the emotional weight of the song.

Foster’s interpretation of “House of the Rising Sun” also plays with dynamics in a way that creates a powerful emotional arc. The song begins quietly and steadily builds, adding intensity to the vocal delivery and the arrangement. As the chorus swells, his voice rises in both volume and emotion, conveying the inner turmoil and regret of the song’s protagonist. By the time he reaches the final lines, there’s a sense of finality and acceptance, as if the character has come to terms with their fate.

One of the most striking aspects of Foster’s cover is how it balances the melancholy of the song with a sense of vulnerability. There’s a fragility in his delivery that makes the song feel personal, as though he is confiding in the listener rather than simply performing a well-known tune. This sense of personal connection is enhanced by the simplicity of the arrangement, which focuses all attention on the vocals and lyrics.

John Foster honored Underwood when he performed “I Told You So,” which is her song with Randy Travis. John noted how supportive Underwood has been for him and wanted to pay tribute to her.

This was John’s first performance without his guitar, but he still delivered. “I’m blushing!” Underwood said. “I love that each challenge you push yourself and you try to do different kinds of songs, you do different things. I love watching you grow every time you take the stage. I’ll speak for Randy Travis on this one, I really think he would approve.”

Who made the top 10?
After the viewers votes were counted, the top 10 was revealed. The artists moving onto next week (read in no particular order) are: John Foster, Josh King, Jamal Roberts, Mattie Pruitt, Thunderstorm Artis, Slater Nalley, Gabby Samone, Canaan James Hill, Kolbi Jordan, and Breanna Nix.

Who was eliminated?
Unfortunately, that left two singers with the least amount of votes, who were eliminated: Che and Filo, who will be headed home. The top 10 will take the stage again on Sunday, May 4.

American Idol, Season 23, Sundays and Mondays, 8/7c, ABC